I Am (Not) Sherlock Holmes

The home I grew up in was not a loving one. It was cold and isolated and, for a young girl who needs to be part of a whole, that was extremely painful. I grew up feeling like an outsider in my own family. Always on the fringes of something that I was too young to understand it was better that I not be included in. All I knew was that I was somehow different from my family members and that translated into an ostracism I didn’t understand. I internalized and took that into myself as evidence of my flawed nature.

A studious child, I took refuge in books. It is not a gross exaggeration to say that I read approximately five books a week growing up. I read every genre and books of all lengths. I read to escape into other worlds and I read to understand how people were supposed to work. What was expected of me as a human being so that I might mimic this behavior and be accepted. I also read in hopes of finding some salvation from the emotional pain I experienced.

What I didn’t understand until last night, was how unbelievably wrong some of my conclusions were.

I am in the last year of a graduate program to obtain a Masters in Fine Arts. My current class is on detective fiction. For my final paper, I’m doing a survey of Sherlock Holmes pastiche. I chose Sherlock Holmes because I, myself, have been fascinated with him since I was child. So this paper is in my wheelhouse.

houndI first discovered Sherlock through the films of Basil Rathbone. From the first one I saw, The Hound of the Baskervilles, I was hooked. I immediately began reading the books and short stories. Eventually, I would collect and read every Holmes story written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I loved Holmes’ objectivity, his detachment and logic. I loved how there was an explanation for everything in his world. No fact was left without a distinct and plausible reason.

For a child who lacked the fundamental understanding of why the people she loved didn’t love her back, this complete certitude was a comfort. There were no unanswered questions at the end of a Holmes story.

My love for this form of mystery only grew and I would eventually devour just as many of Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple novels and any other form of mystery so long as they were in the same mode. My television watching was the same I loved Murder She Wrote, etc.

Even the science fiction I embraced had a very Holmesian figure – Star Trek’s Mr. Spock. Again, I was drawn to his logic. To his cold detachment and ability to control his emotions. He saw emotion as a weakness and so did I.

With these literary figures as my role models, the only conclusion  to my child’s mind was to do away with emotion. It served no purpose and only weakened you and gave power over you to others.

I didn’t understand until last night how the choices I’d made in reading had influenced my emotional health and how my emotional health had influenced my choices in reading. I chose novels and books that satisfied a need for order in my emotionally troubled life. The characters had mastered an area of life which, in my own, represented pain and disorder. I wanted nothing to do with the emotions that battered me and left me feeling so unbelievably hurt.

Miss-Marple_35231x1Looking back, I can even see the pattern and transition. It would be after my aborted suicide attempt that I really became obsessed with Holmes, Marple and Spock. I was seeking a way to control the pain when what I should have been doing was finding a way to deal with my emotions.

You see, I am an intensely emotional person. Not deeply emotional. Intensely. The distinction is that I freely admit that I don’t have consistently deep emotions. I can in fact be very shallow. But when I do experience something emotionally, it’s intense. Therefore, the slights and humiliations I experienced growing up would take on epic proportions emotionally when they got under my skin, and I had no way to deal with it or to understand it. The people who were supposed to be teaching me these things were the ones perpetrating the acts.

As an adult, I can see that I made the wrong decision. I chose to suppress my emotions all together and that placed me on a very self-destructive path. I see now that I cannot repress and deny my emotions. I need to seek to understand them and get them into perspective.

It’s not easy. I tend to cry the instant I start talking about anything emotional. Every emotion I experience has the same effect on me now and I’m left feeling like a wrung out rag when it’s done. It’s a strange thing to be afraid of your own emotions, but I admit I am.

I only hope that with this realization, I can work toward a healthier mind state. I’ll always love Holmes, Marple and Spock. They got me through a very tough time in my life, but I don’t need them anymore. I need me.

6 thoughts on “I Am (Not) Sherlock Holmes

  1. As a counsellor, I used to think about using fiction as a tool – therapy through reading and applying insights gained to one’s own life. You have had a great revelation brought about by analyzing which novels spoke to you at certain times of your life. A rich experience made even more so by your ability to write about it. But of course – not easy and painful to boot. Keep reading, keep getting curious about your reactions to things. Little by little – recovering from the types of things you describe is like peeling an onion – always one more layer giving way to yet another layer. You can’t rush the process.

  2. I came to a similar realization regarding my reading and hobbies. It’s funny the little shells we construct to protect ourselves and how easy it is to find ourselves walled into our safe place with no escape.

  3. I too found comfort in Sherlock Holmes growing up. Funny how coping mechanisms for people can be so similar. I’m happy to read that you figured this out and that your post was upbeat about it. Emotions can suck, lets face it, but without the bad you’ll never know how good it can be to feel good. But hey I’m one to talk, right? 🙂 Great post as always, I love your writing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s