Why Do Thousands of People and The Huffington Post Think This is Okay?

I opened up The Huffington Post this morning, like I do most days, and gladly clicked on the headline “World’s Gentlest Dog Befriends Little Boy With Down Syndrome, Melts Our Hearts”. I love stuff like this. I’m a dog lover and general sucker for feel good stories. As I watched the video, my heart was anything but melted. In truth, I was greatly concerned by what I saw. If you haven’t watched it already, it’s a short 4-minute video below:

Now, I’m no Cesar Milan, but I have some issues with what I’m seeing. Maybe I’m wrong and if so, great, but as both a parent and a responsible dog owner, I would not have let this interaction continue uninterrupted and I would not have been laughing. Here’s what bugged me:

  • The little boy evidences tension and a distinct desire for the dog to leave him alone. In a child without Down Syndrome, it would not be acceptable to leave them in a situation where they are essentially being dominated by a canine. In a child with Down Syndrome, who likely has even less effective communication tools at their disposable, you must be even more vigilant. My issue here is you don’t even NEED a translation of intent by the toddler. He doesn’t want the dog messing with him. That’s a full stop both for a parent and a dog owner.
  • While the dog – a female – is clearly trying to be friendly, the problem is that she is controlling the situation. In any human-dog interaction, human must always be the leader. This goes for children as well. When our children can’t vocalize for themselves, we must do it for them. It is not acceptable for a dog to believe any human baby is their puppy. This can lead to unintended, yet tragic accidents.

Despite the headline, this dog never managed to befriend this child. Right up until the last second, the toddler wanted nothing to do with the dog. His parents had a responsibility to respect that. In my mind, all they did was create tension and potentially distrust in their child.

Again, this is just me. Maybe the fact that I raise Pit Bulls is  clouding my perspective. We would never allow our Pit Bulls to continue to pressure anyone, let alone a defenseless child.

6 thoughts on “Why Do Thousands of People and The Huffington Post Think This is Okay?

  1. What made me clearly uncomfortable was what happened from 3:14 on, with the child hugging/groping the dog’s head. I know many dogs, most of whom wouldn’t mind such an action. But I do not know the one in the video. Dogs and children is a difficult topic.

  2. I agree the interaction was troublesome. The child was clearly curious but bothered by the dog’s touch. As a special needs educator, I can tell you that SOME (I’m speaking in generalizations here) children with Down Syndrome may exhibit some distress when faced with certain sensations. Some textures are unpleasant. That may be the case with this little boy. The little boy likes the dog’s foot on a clothed part of his body, where he is not directly touching him, but does not like the feeling of the dogs fur or mouth. A more structured, graduated approach may have been more beneficial if trying to perform sensory integration.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s